Lost Colony of Roanoke: Mystery of England's First American Settlers

Lost Colony of Roanoke: Mystery of England's First American Settlers

Released Thursday, 12th September 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Lost Colony of Roanoke: Mystery of England's First American Settlers

Lost Colony of Roanoke: Mystery of England's First American Settlers

Lost Colony of Roanoke: Mystery of England's First American Settlers

Lost Colony of Roanoke: Mystery of England's First American Settlers

Thursday, 12th September 2024
Good episode? Give it some love!
Rate Episode

Episode Transcript

Transcripts are displayed as originally observed. Some content, including advertisements may have changed.

Use Ctrl + F to search

0:00

Odoo is business management made so simple a

0:02

kid could explain it sometimes business

0:04

software can't talk to other

0:06

programs But Odoo funny

0:09

word has every program from

0:11

CRM to HR to accounting

0:13

in one platform It

0:15

should cost a lot, but it doesn't so

0:18

you should use Odoo because they save you

0:20

money Odoo makes a lot

0:22

of sense, but doesn't cost a lot of sense

0:24

sign up now at Odoo calm. That's OD

0:26

oh Com good

0:29

job Thanks the new boost mobile

0:31

network is offering unlimited talk text and data

0:33

for just $25 a month for life That

0:37

sounds like a threat then how do you think we should

0:39

say unlimited talk text and data for just $25 a month

0:41

for? The rest

0:43

of your life. I don't know Until

0:45

your ultimate demise what if

0:48

we just say forever okay $25 a month

0:50

forever get unlimited talk text and data for just $25

0:52

a month with boost mobile After

0:55

30 gigabytes customers may experience slower speeds customers will

0:57

pay $25 a month as long as they

0:59

remain active on the boost unlimited plan Deep

1:01

in the ocean an orca pod is on

1:04

the hunt these aren't your

1:06

average orcas These guys

1:08

are organized Marketing

1:10

team did you get those social media post

1:12

scheduled for the seal migration? Hi,

1:14

I captain we even have an automated notification

1:16

for all pod managers when they go live

1:20

They use Monday calm to keep their teamwork

1:22

sharp their communication clear and their goals in

1:24

sight Monday calm for

1:26

whatever you run even orcas go

1:29

to Monday calm to dive deeper This

1:40

is the story of one of America's

1:42

greatest Mysteries the lost colony

1:44

of Roanoke and the attempt by

1:46

the English to establish a colony

1:48

on the shores of the North

1:50

American continent in

1:54

1587 a hundred and fifteen

1:56

settlers vanished without a trace

2:00

The only clue they left behind was

2:02

the word Croatoan carved into a

2:04

tree. Myths

2:06

swirl around this history.

2:09

The truth, however, is

2:11

complex. But

2:14

for now, it's 1585 and

2:16

we're in a secondhand village

2:18

on the Pamlico River in

2:20

North Carolina. It's two

2:22

years before the Lost Colony will

2:24

be, well, lost. Englishman

2:27

John White is sketching the scene

2:30

before him. The tobacco

2:32

crop, the field of ripe maize,

2:34

the low houses, the makeshift chapel

2:37

and the burial ground. The

2:40

villagers are eating their meals

2:42

talking soberly. He's sketching

2:44

the tilled earth and the pumpkins

2:46

that spring bulbous from it, a

2:49

shock of colour in a land

2:51

of autumnal greys and browns. But

2:54

take all of this with a pinch of salt. Although

2:57

John White is a passable artist,

2:59

he doesn't have the best eye

3:02

for detail. For instance, he's

3:04

given some of the people before him

3:06

two right feet. Not

3:08

far away from this sketcher sits

3:11

his guide, Mantello, of the

3:14

Croatoan tribe. He's

3:16

spent much of the previous year living

3:18

in London in the house of Sir

3:20

Walter Raleigh and is no stranger to

3:22

settlers looking to expand their reach in

3:24

the New World. Now

3:26

he's returned to act as an

3:29

intermediary in England's first

3:31

attempt to establish a permanent

3:33

foothold on this continent. If

3:36

we're to understand the mystery of

3:38

the Lost Colony, we need to

3:40

start here to try to unpick

3:42

this badly drawn picture of

3:44

the first faltering steps

3:46

of English colonisation. Thank

3:56

you. I

4:00

am so intrigued by this. Welcome

4:13

back, by the way, to After Dark Towers. I'm Antony. And

4:16

I'm Maddie. And we've been languishing in these towers

4:18

for the last however many days, waiting for you all to

4:20

come back and listen to another bizarre

4:23

or dark history. And today we are looking

4:25

at one of the greatest mysteries in

4:27

history, the fate of the lost colony of

4:29

Roanoke. And our guest today, and we

4:31

have long been asking for Misha to be

4:33

one of our guests, but it's Dr.

4:35

Misha Ewen, a lecturer in early modern history

4:38

at the University of Sussex and author

4:40

of The Great Virginia Venture, American

4:42

Colonization and English Society, 1580 to 1660.

4:46

Misha, we're so glad to have you at long

4:48

last. Yes, it's so nice to be here and

4:50

see both your faces as well. Thank you for

4:52

inviting me. Not at all. It

4:54

is absolutely our pleasure. Now I'm going to ask

4:56

you to do some very basic

4:59

background on this, because for those who

5:01

may not be familiar with the mystery

5:03

of Roanoke, so let's let's read the

5:05

history for a second. What

5:08

exactly is the mystery? Okay,

5:10

so as you've already suggested, it

5:12

does become known as the lost

5:14

colony and the lost colonists. And

5:17

this is because in 1590, when

5:19

John White, who you've already mentioned,

5:21

returns to Roanoke. So after he's

5:23

voyaged back to England to resupply,

5:25

there's been a stay of shipping

5:28

because of the Spanish Armada in

5:30

1588. Elizabeth says, you

5:32

know, no ships can go. We can't risk, you

5:34

know, losing any of our precious shipping. We're at

5:36

war. He tries to make

5:38

his way there by hiring smaller privateer

5:40

ships. He doesn't manage to reach it.

5:42

And when he does finally get back

5:45

there in 1590, there is no sign

5:47

of any of the colonists. He can

5:49

see that they've pulled down the houses,

5:51

which suggests that it was a deliberate

5:54

abandonment, if you like, of the colony, that, you know,

5:56

they were not kind of hurried or rushed from the

5:58

site. can see is

6:00

sketched into one of the palisaded posts

6:03

is this word Croatoan, which suggests that

6:05

well, he thinks that perhaps that's where

6:08

the colonists have gone to seek refuge

6:10

with local indigenous people. The

6:12

colonists are never found, but

6:15

within several generations when English colonists again

6:17

returned to this region and established Jamestown,

6:19

there were all different kinds of reports

6:21

about what might have happened to them.

6:24

Even you know kind of 130 years

6:26

later when English men are surveying in

6:28

that area, they also hear stories from indigenous

6:31

people about what might have happened to

6:33

these English settlers and this continues right

6:35

through into the 20th century

6:38

and around 1937 when there's

6:40

the 350 year anniversary of the establishment

6:45

of the colony. There are all different kinds

6:47

of commemorative events so it's very much a

6:50

part of the origin story of the

6:52

United States and particularly individuals are kind

6:54

of picked out from this story as

6:56

you know they're mythologised in ways that

6:58

are quite disturbing as well and perhaps

7:00

we might come on to talk about

7:02

that later but yeah it's very much

7:04

in the story of English America this

7:06

is the starting point and yeah there

7:08

is this mystery which surrounds what happened

7:10

to the people and the fascination not

7:12

just since but also at the

7:14

time of what became of them.

7:16

This doesn't often happen to me on after

7:19

dark but I actually have goosebumps and it's

7:21

not just because we're changing from summer into

7:23

autumn but I think this is

7:25

such an interesting story it has so many mysterious

7:28

elements and so many different types of history

7:30

coming in here we've got the history of

7:32

colonization we've got as you say this kind

7:34

of myth making around early America we've got

7:37

you reference there the Spanish Armada and things

7:39

happening back in England so

7:41

let's get into some of the concrete history

7:43

that we know we know that the Lost

7:45

Colony as it's going to go on to

7:47

be called is founded in 1587 but there's

7:49

a previous failed

7:53

colony from 1585 two

7:55

years earlier as well so why

7:57

are the English trying to

7:59

build this settlement, this stronghold

8:02

in this part of North America in this moment,

8:05

Misha. Yeah, so I guess

8:07

the backdrop to this is, you

8:09

know, by this point almost a century of

8:11

English exploration, if you

8:13

like, in parts of North America,

8:16

so much further north in present-day

8:18

Canada, seeking the Northwest Passage, but

8:21

also in what we now think of

8:23

as, you know, the eastern coast of

8:25

North America, which was coined Virginia by

8:27

Raleigh, but also parts of Newfoundland as

8:29

well in Atlantic Canada. So they have

8:32

been going into these places,

8:34

trying to establish settlements in search

8:36

of natural resources. They are encountering

8:38

indigenous people and hearing different kinds

8:41

of stories about, you know, gold

8:43

and silver mines and tin mines,

8:45

and they're thinking about the

8:47

ways in which they can exploit

8:49

the natural riches of this region.

8:51

But importantly, for the English at

8:53

this time, the Chesapeake region and

8:55

Roanoke and what will later become

8:57

Virginia hasn't yet been claimed by

8:59

another European power. And that's really

9:01

important, because obviously we don't really

9:04

want to have direct conflict

9:06

if we can avoid it. But you

9:08

mentioned the Spanish Armada, and this is

9:10

obviously occurring against the backdrop

9:12

of the reformation and rivalry between what

9:14

is now Protestant England and Catholic Spain,

9:16

and this sense in which if they

9:18

can get a foothold in the Chesapeake

9:20

first, which is thought of

9:23

by other Europeans as being a

9:25

tactically advantageous spot, but also rich

9:28

in natural resources, that from this

9:30

point, the English can begin to

9:32

expand their New World Empire and

9:35

begin to counter Spanish

9:37

influence in what is then, you know,

9:40

the Caribbean and parts of South America.

9:42

And when they go in 1585

9:46

to 86, I guess what's

9:48

a little bit different from what comes

9:50

later is that at that point, they're only sending boys

9:52

and men. It's very much a

9:54

military garrison. They are obviously kind of

9:56

making exploratory missions whilst they're there. to

9:59

try and you know survey the land

10:01

and like you say white produces all

10:03

of these drawings, both of the people

10:05

but also the plants and the animals

10:07

in that area. But when they return

10:09

in 1587 with this much

10:12

larger group including these family groups, women,

10:14

some women who are pregnant as well,

10:17

there's much more of a sense of

10:19

establishing a civilian colony and that's actually

10:21

very new and unique for the English

10:23

in the 16th century and is obviously

10:26

what will then become the model for

10:28

English settlement in the 17th century. So

10:30

there are lots of ways in which Roanoke

10:32

kind of creates a blueprint for what will

10:34

come later even though it

10:36

isn't successful in the way that English

10:39

colonists would have liked. Let's

10:41

put some of those characters back into

10:43

that settlement then. Two that you've mentioned

10:46

so far are Montayo and John White.

10:48

Can you tell us a little bit

10:50

about both of those people? So

10:53

John White is from London. He

10:56

is employed by Raleigh because he

10:58

has a range

11:00

of different skills I guess that he

11:02

can bring to this colonial venture but

11:04

primarily it's to record what he sees

11:06

as Maddy's already mentioned. Both the people,

11:09

the kinds of settlements that they encounter

11:11

but also the flora and the fauna

11:13

as well. He's married,

11:15

he has a daughter, several

11:17

grandchildren, a son-in-law and they

11:19

join the later colony in

11:22

1587 with him. Montayo like

11:24

Maddy said has spent some time in London,

11:27

in the household of Raleigh. He

11:29

has been informing them about the region acting

11:31

as a go-between but also you know that

11:33

this real sense that at this time there

11:36

is knowledge exchange between

11:38

Indigenous people and English colonists,

11:40

this kind of two-way relationship

11:42

and he then returns with

11:45

them in 1587 back to the region and the

11:47

idea is that he can help to broker

11:49

good relations with the local

11:51

Indigenous population. He's also

11:54

joined in London by another

11:56

Indigenous man named Woncheezy who

11:59

also stays on the Strand at

12:01

Raleigh's property and they're

12:03

involved in later

12:05

with helping to produce different

12:08

texts and kind of you know

12:10

create these very early

12:12

guides if you like for colonists about

12:14

the kind of the language, the customs, the

12:16

culture of the people, something that they can

12:18

use when they go back to

12:21

these parts of North America to

12:23

establish the colonies. Should we

12:25

be surprised Misha that the

12:27

Indigenous people who just described that

12:30

they're looking to collaborate with colonists.

12:32

This maybe isn't the narrative that

12:35

we understand from our modern perspective. I'm

12:38

assuming that that's not a blanket

12:40

case across all of

12:42

the Indigenous tribes living in the areas that

12:44

are being colonised by the English and indeed

12:46

by the Spanish but is this an unusual

12:48

situation or is this something that's been cultivated

12:50

by both sides if you like? Yeah

12:53

so definitely not unusual, definitely being cultivated

12:55

by both sides but I think also

12:57

there's a spectrum isn't there? So a

13:00

spectrum in terms of I guess how

13:02

consensual sometimes these journeys are, these relationships

13:04

are, you know I think what historians

13:06

appreciate more today than perhaps we did

13:09

a few generations ago is that you

13:11

know this is also occurring against a

13:13

really complex backdrop of Indigenous politics and

13:16

different rivalries and things that they are

13:18

seeking from brokering relationships with different European

13:20

groups, ways they might advantage

13:22

their own political groups versus

13:24

others and there is a pattern

13:27

as well of the English bringing

13:29

these go-betweens back to England

13:31

with them and that's something

13:33

which also continues into the 17th century as

13:35

well. It's something that we see recurring again

13:38

and again, this sense of collaboration both on

13:40

producing you know new texts and knowledge about

13:43

the so-called new world and but

13:45

also using them on the ground

13:47

as well to help broker these

13:49

political relationships with local leaders but

13:51

also acting as interpreters as well

13:53

but I do think that we do have

13:55

an appreciation now that sometimes this is also

13:57

coming about through the motivations of the world.

14:00

of Indigenous people and it's not just

14:02

completely one-sided. So, Misha, we've

14:04

got this early settlement

14:06

that we know fails before we

14:09

get the lost colony that disappears,

14:12

that vanishes without a trace. So

14:14

let's just focus on that first

14:16

iteration of the settlement then. We

14:18

know it fails. Do we know

14:20

why? Well, as I mentioned before,

14:22

it's very much a military

14:24

garrison. So it's populated by men and

14:26

boys and it's a

14:28

very violent colony as well. So

14:31

it's led by Ralph Lane who

14:33

goes on to massacre and kill

14:35

one of the local leaders, a

14:37

man named Wing Gina. So

14:39

relations with the local Indigenous people

14:41

completely breaks down, which is counter

14:43

to their plans because they think that

14:45

they need to have good relations with

14:48

local Indigenous people in order to broker

14:50

diplomatic relations but also to use their

14:52

knowledge about the region and the local

14:54

resources that they're planning to exploit. So

14:57

they decide actually the English colonists that Roanoke isn't

14:59

a suitable location for a settlement and when they

15:01

return in 1587 the intention is

15:04

that they'll actually make their way much

15:06

further north to the Chesapeake but they're

15:09

dropped off in Roanoke kind of against

15:11

their will and their plans and

15:13

that's how it unfolds from that point. Well,

15:35

After Dark listeners, we have an introduction to

15:37

make on today's podcast and the person we'd

15:39

like to introduce is probably somebody you already

15:41

know and if you don't, you should get

15:43

to know his podcast and that of course

15:45

is Dan Snow, host of Dan Snow's History

15:47

Hit. Dan, welcome to After Dark. Hey guys,

15:49

well, it's a great honour to be on

15:51

the podcast tickly because it's now such a

15:54

behemoth. It's such a juggernaut. I'm very

15:56

excited. Are you enjoying being part of

15:58

the history hit family? Oh,

16:01

we absolutely are. It's been such a joy.

16:03

And early on, it was so nice to

16:05

borrow presenters from different history hit podcasts and,

16:07

you know, get to know everyone a little

16:10

bit, get to know everyone's different approaches and

16:12

perspectives to history. And I think, Dan, we're

16:14

going to talk not about our own podcast

16:16

here, but about your podcast and the thing

16:19

that I love and have to admit to

16:21

you, I have been a real genuine listener

16:23

of your pod for many years, not to,

16:25

you know, out you on the age front

16:28

here, Dan, but I really have been genuinely

16:30

a fan. And one thing that

16:32

I love in terms of that perspective, the angle

16:34

that you bring is that it's

16:36

so you make history so relevant in terms of

16:38

what's happening in the headlines right now. Is that

16:41

just your perspective on history, Dan? Is that just

16:43

how you see the past and present and how

16:45

they interlink? Thanks, Maddie. Yeah, I bet you've been

16:47

listening to it ever since you were in primary

16:49

school. Of course. My passion, I

16:51

came for a family of journalists, but

16:54

I always loved history. As you say, history is urgent.

16:56

History is the reason that we've got too much

16:58

carbon in our atmosphere. It's the reason that America

17:01

and China are eyeing each other up in

17:03

the South China Sea. It's the reason that

17:05

Vladimir Putin thinks Eastern or all

17:07

of Ukraine is part of Russia. All

17:09

of these things which are affecting our lives, those

17:12

of our families, loved ones, children and their children

17:14

and their children, all of those things are

17:17

deeply rooted in our past. So my

17:19

passion is those episodes where I

17:22

take up something that we're seeing today,

17:24

Ukraine, the fervor of the American election,

17:26

Brexit, Taiwan and

17:28

Middle East Israel, Palestine, and

17:31

I try and look into the deep history of it. That

17:33

is my passion. Having said that, I also just love banging

17:35

out an episode in Francis Drake or

17:37

Florence Nightingale. It's a great narrative stories and history.

17:39

I like doing both. I've always wanted my pod.

17:41

I've never wanted to pin it down. I think

17:43

like you guys with your podcast, you actually wanted

17:45

to find yourself as widely as possible because it

17:47

just makes it more interesting for us when we

17:49

go to work. But one of the things that

17:51

works really well, I think, on your podcast and

17:53

if there are after dark listeners who don't listen

17:56

to Dan's podcast do because one of the things

17:58

we share in common is... this

18:00

broad view, but really bringing in,

18:02

as you're saying, Dan, individual narratives

18:04

to help locate those

18:06

histories within people's lives and within the

18:09

lives of people who are listening today.

18:12

And what kind of narrative drive do

18:14

you think mostly appeals to you when

18:16

it comes to history? Because, you know, we can

18:18

all do facts and figures, we can all Google,

18:21

but what is it about those big sweeps of

18:23

narrative history that really gets your interest peaked? Well,

18:25

you said it better than I could do, I

18:27

think, really, but it's the fact that it's the

18:29

greatest, they're the greatest stories ever told, like the

18:32

best stories are true stories. And

18:34

then as well as these incredible dramatic arcs

18:36

that touch the lives of everybody, it's the

18:38

human beings within them. It's the fact

18:40

that we know enough about what it

18:43

was like to be Archduke Franz Ferdinand as he

18:45

drove through the streets of Sarajevo that day. We

18:47

kind of have a pretty good idea of what

18:49

was going through Kaiser Wilhelm's head as he mulled

18:52

over the big decisions and Zarnikolas as they

18:54

mulled over the decisions that basically plunged the

18:56

world into catastrophic war and condemned their

18:59

own families and their own

19:01

regimes to oblivion or worse. So it's just

19:03

those, as you say, the individuals being caught

19:05

up in it is so fascinating. So it's

19:07

telling the big story and then cutting back

19:09

and reminding everyone that there are families

19:12

and humans driving

19:14

these events and becoming caught up in these

19:17

events. Thinking about some

19:19

of those stories that we have in

19:21

common, Dan, and some of those human

19:23

elements that drive us all, I think,

19:25

to tell history, the thing

19:28

that I think we share is a

19:30

love of stories and history set on

19:32

ships. Now, we have covered

19:34

so many ships on After Dark and they're always the

19:36

most popular. We've done The Bounty, we've done HMS Terror,

19:39

recently listened down to your episode on

19:42

HMS Wager. I say, listen, I ran

19:44

to that. I have never downloaded anything

19:46

quicker in my entire life. But

19:48

for After Dark listeners who do love a

19:51

ship story, can you recommend any episodes on

19:53

your pod or indeed episodes that are not

19:55

set on ships that the people absolutely need

19:57

to hear? So yeah, HMS Wager.

19:59

you mentioned, that's just a story

20:02

that you couldn't make up. Shipwreck and

20:04

Mutiny, Murder, an astonishing

20:06

escape story. And

20:08

that's true of episodes, for example, on Mutiny on

20:11

the Bounty, Captain Blarne the Bounty. I would

20:13

quite like to recent one, was Scott's expedition

20:15

to the South Pole, was it actually sabotaged?

20:18

It was definitely let down by, well,

20:21

perhaps incompetence on the part of many

20:23

people involved, but was it actually maliciously

20:25

sabotaged? That's the big question. That's a

20:27

huge one. But if people want to get

20:30

away from the ice and the water, the desert

20:32

and the mountains are available. So I've done a

20:34

series on Ancient Egypt recently, and a series on

20:36

the Inca in the Andes, which was an amazing

20:38

experience. I got to walk the Inca trail through

20:40

the Andes and just explored a

20:42

civilization I knew nothing about. Well,

20:45

you heard it here, folks. You can get your

20:47

news and your alt from

20:49

Dan Snow's history here, wherever

20:52

you get your podcasts. And

20:54

honestly, you will not regret

20:56

it. Download every episode right

20:59

now. Homeowners,

21:04

if you want to sell your house

21:06

fast for all cash, stop what you

21:08

are doing and listen to this because

21:10

Osborn Homes wants to buy your house

21:12

right now. I'm Alec from Osborn Homes,

21:14

and we want to buy your house.

21:16

Nobody buys more homes in California than

21:18

Osborn, whether it's a total fixer upper

21:20

or in perfect condition. Osborn Homes is

21:22

the easiest way to sell your house

21:24

fast, all cash. Best of all, when

21:26

you sell your house to Osborn Homes,

21:28

there are zero commissions, zero fees, plus

21:31

no banks, no realtors, no repairs, and

21:33

no waiting to close. We buy your

21:35

house as is all cash. Just go

21:37

to Osborn homes.com right now to get

21:39

your free, no obligation, all cash offer.

21:41

We are here and ready to buy

21:43

your house 24 hours a day, seven

21:45

days a week. Just go to Osborn

21:47

Homes dot com. Go to Osborn homes.com

21:49

right now. Don't wait. Sell your house

21:51

to Osborn Homes and put the cash

21:53

in your pocket right away. Just go

21:55

to Osborn Homes dot com. That's Osborn

21:57

Homes dot com. Osborn Homes dot com.

22:00

osbornehomes.com. Deep

22:04

in the ocean, an orca pod is on

22:06

the hunt. These aren't your

22:08

average orcas. These guys

22:10

are organized. Marketing

22:13

team, did you get those social media posts

22:15

scheduled for the seal migration? Aye,

22:17

aye, Captain. We even have an automated notification

22:19

for all pod managers when they go live.

22:22

They use monday.com to keep their

22:24

teamwork sharp, their communication clear, and

22:26

their goals in sight. monday.com for

22:29

whatever you run, even orcas. Go

22:31

to monday.com to dive deeper. This

22:36

episode is brought to you by BetterHelp.

22:39

Children are always learning and growing.

22:41

But as adults, sometimes we lose

22:43

that curiosity. So what's

22:45

something you would like to learn? Gardening, or

22:48

a new language, or maybe how to finally

22:50

beat your best friend in bowling? Now,

22:52

Anthony, I have been trying to learn

22:54

Italian for several months now. And there

22:56

are mixed results, let's say. But I'm

22:58

giving it a go. And that's what

23:00

counts. That is what counts. And therapy

23:02

can help you to reconnect with your sense

23:04

of wonder, because your back-to-school era can come

23:07

at any age. It can also

23:09

teach you positive coping skills and how

23:11

to set boundaries. It empowers you to

23:13

be the best version of yourself. It

23:16

isn't just for those who've experienced major

23:18

trauma. It could even help you if

23:21

you're feeling just a little bit stuck

23:23

in your life. If you're

23:25

thinking of starting therapy, give BetterHelp a

23:27

try. It's entirely online, designed

23:30

to be convenient, flexible, and

23:32

suited to your schedule. Just

23:34

fill out a brief questionnaire

23:36

to get matched with a

23:38

licensed therapist. And switch therapists

23:41

any time for no additional

23:43

charge. Visit betterhelp.com/afterdarkpod today to

23:45

get 10% off your first

23:47

month. That's

23:50

betterhelp, H-E-L-P,.com/afterdarkpod.

24:00

Right, so we have this contextual

24:03

information around what the colonizers are doing

24:05

here and what's happening on the ground

24:07

and the relationship they have with the

24:10

indigenous people but let's get a little

24:12

bit more into the detail of the

24:14

lost colony of Roanoke and Maddie is

24:16

going to give us a little bit

24:18

more detail. It's

24:23

1587 now. Once

24:29

again we are with John White in

24:31

the middle of a settlement in what

24:33

is now North Carolina. It's

24:36

a dark night on Roanoke Island and

24:38

he sits by a small fire in

24:40

the middle of the doomed English colony.

24:44

Up to now he has been

24:46

a bit part player, watching and

24:48

sketching from the sidelines, documenting progress

24:51

and considering his part in

24:53

the new world. But now

24:55

he's the leader of a

24:57

whole new operation. Around

25:00

him almost a hundred souls all

25:03

fated to become the lost colonists,

25:06

sleeping peacefully. But

25:08

don't picture them slumbering inside log

25:10

cabins as later illustrations would have

25:12

it. Instead they're

25:14

huddled in crude lean-to's made from

25:16

the bush and gathered together for

25:18

warmth. As White sits

25:21

frowning into the fire a cry breaks

25:23

out in the dark and for a

25:25

moment a smile crosses his face. Because

25:28

with that cry new life is

25:30

heralded, his granddaughter has just come

25:33

healthy and screaming into the world.

25:36

And her arrival marks a significant

25:38

turning point for those who've made

25:40

it to this far offshore because

25:43

she is the very first person to be

25:45

born to an English mother on

25:47

this entire continent. She

25:49

will even take its name, Virginia.

25:52

Virginia Dare. When

25:55

all is lost and gone her name

25:57

will linger on and the myths around

25:59

her. will grow and grow

26:01

and grow. Right,

26:10

so this, Misha, this is the trip

26:12

that gets lost. Who do we have

26:14

here and what would this group

26:17

of people have looked like? What's different about

26:19

this? They're quite an average bunch

26:21

of people in a way. So

26:23

John White lives in London, his family

26:25

live in London. And evidence would suggest

26:27

that most of this group are known

26:29

to each other. So, you know, lots

26:31

of them share the same surnames. They

26:33

attend the same parish churches. The

26:36

group is mostly from the city of

26:38

London. They're not kind of widely dispersed,

26:40

as you do find, with the settlement

26:42

of Jamestown, much later, for example. There

26:44

are brothers, there are cousins, there are

26:46

husbands and wives. Some have

26:49

children, some of the children are left behind

26:51

in England with relatives, some of the children are

26:53

brought with them, including some very

26:55

young infants. And in terms

26:57

of their social status, they are sort

26:59

of middling kind of people. So some

27:01

of them like John White's own son-in-law

27:03

are skilled. So he's a stone carver,

27:05

for example. And I guess they would

27:07

have tried to recruit people who had

27:09

some kind of useful skills. So they

27:11

might be carpenters, for example, bricklayers. So

27:13

they're not the kind of lowest people

27:16

in the kind of rungs of society,

27:18

but they're also not gentry. They're probably

27:20

not landowners either. Scholars

27:23

think that perhaps several of them might

27:26

be Puritans and that might help explain

27:28

some of their motivation as well. And

27:30

I think certainly they're Protestants. So I guess there is

27:33

a sense in which, there is a

27:35

religious motivation here, that they're kind of going to

27:37

the new world to settle this

27:39

colony, to help supplant Catholic

27:42

Spain's influence in the region.

27:45

So we do know a fair bit about the

27:47

makeup. We know all of their names. We know that

27:49

about 17 of them are women. And this, from

27:52

an English point of view, is completely

27:54

novel in this time. We haven't

27:56

had so far in English

27:58

history, groups of people. women being part

28:01

of these colonial ventures. And I think

28:03

that is interesting because it obviously suggests

28:05

that there is a sense of creating

28:07

a permanent stable society. It isn't just

28:09

going to be extractive, although it will

28:12

be extractive and exploitative as well, but

28:14

this sense in which they are very

28:16

much trying to replicate English society. And

28:18

of course you need women to be

28:20

able to do that through giving birth

28:23

to the next generation as Eleanor Deere

28:25

does when she gives birth to her

28:27

daughter Virginia. I love this idea,

28:29

Misha, that it's a community who

28:32

are all based in London originally and

28:34

they're sort of transplanted almost as a

28:37

whole to the New World, which is fascinating

28:39

because as you say in later settlements,

28:42

it's very much not the case and

28:44

you get people drawn in from all

28:46

different walks of life and different racial

28:48

identities, different classes. So it's a real

28:51

melting pot of people to better and

28:53

worse effect really. And it's just

28:55

thinking about the mystery and knowing what we now

28:58

know is going to happen to this colony, or

29:00

at least we know that something happens even if

29:02

the details still evade us. That there's something slightly

29:05

claustrophobic about the fact that everyone

29:07

probably knows, well certainly by the

29:09

time they arrive on the American

29:11

continent, everyone knows each other and

29:14

people are already expecting children,

29:16

they've brought children with them.

29:18

It feels like a very closed

29:21

off world and that seems

29:23

quite frightening to me. Do you think that was

29:25

the case? Do you think there would have been

29:27

this element of claustrophobia? Yeah, so you can

29:29

imagine it's really intense because as you say,

29:31

these are people who are already known to

29:34

each other but they've made this long journey

29:36

whilst some of these women are already heavily

29:38

pregnant too. And now

29:40

that you sort of raised that issue, it makes me think

29:43

about how traumatic it would have

29:45

then been for the families and communities

29:47

left behind in London when this entire

29:49

group of people just disappear from their

29:51

lives as well because in a way

29:53

it was so concentrated. And that is

29:56

very different from what becomes later, obviously

29:58

through the 17th century in which large larger

30:00

numbers of people take part

30:02

in colonisation in their thousands

30:04

and thousands, but there

30:06

is this sense of it being much

30:09

more widely dispersed. It must have been

30:11

really frightening as well and a real

30:13

sense of vulnerability because the group did

30:15

include pregnant women and

30:18

children who would have been less able

30:20

to defend themselves if that was necessary.

30:22

I wonder if that has added to this

30:25

sense of mystery and the reasons why they

30:27

have been mythologised because of the presence of

30:29

women within this group. I wonder if it

30:31

would have come about in the same

30:33

way had they not been there, but I

30:36

think that has contributed. I think gender

30:38

is a huge part of this

30:40

story and the ways in which it has

30:43

been mythologised and race as well, actually. So

30:45

how quickly did things start to go wrong

30:48

then? What was the turning point?

30:50

Was it a collection of things that happened?

30:52

Certainly it starts to unravel, but how

30:54

does that happen? I mean in some ways

30:57

it is quite undramatic. They just

30:59

think we are going to need more supplies, you are

31:01

going to have to go back to England, but they

31:03

see this as something which will be relatively straightforward, the

31:06

ships will be returned within a few

31:08

months, everyone will still be there and

31:10

yet it is the change in political

31:12

context in Europe which really creates the

31:15

disaster and this two-year delay in

31:17

being able to return. So it

31:19

is hard to know what then

31:22

happens on the ground. I think

31:25

as someone who studies later colonization in

31:27

North America, I can imagine that they

31:29

ran out of food very quickly. If

31:32

relations with the local indigenous people

31:35

had broken down, they might

31:37

have been unwilling to trade food with them, but

31:39

they also just might not have had enough food.

31:41

You know a bad winter and a bad harvest

31:43

can mean that you don't have enough for your

31:46

own people, never mind to share with these newcomers.

31:49

There could have been outbreaks of

31:51

illness and disease, although we know it is

31:53

quite a healthy site, they would have had

31:55

access to fresh clean water and like in

31:57

Jamestown where there were lots of issues with

31:59

very... brackish salty water, but still,

32:01

you know, a whole host of things. And

32:04

also if you do have women as part

32:06

of the group who are becoming pregnant and

32:08

going through childbirth, you know, many of them

32:10

might have died in, you know, from childbirth

32:12

complications. So you can imagine that maybe after

32:14

a year or two, the number of this

32:16

group could have been depleted, very weakened anyway,

32:19

even if the supply mission had made it back

32:22

quicker, you know, how many colonists would

32:24

have still been healthy and alive at

32:26

that point anyway. You mentioned Misha as

32:28

well, this racial element. And we know

32:30

that John White initially has

32:33

this one person, Mantello,

32:35

with him as a sort

32:37

of go-between, maybe as a figure who can

32:40

speak to everyone in

32:42

that local area, including the colonists, and

32:44

sort of negotiate those relations. But

32:47

that peacefulness, that collaboration

32:49

doesn't last very long, does it?

32:51

There is tension between the colonists

32:54

and the Native Americans in that

32:56

region, right? Yeah. And I

32:58

think this also is just a recurring

33:00

theme into the 17th century as well.

33:03

There are always violent

33:05

skirmishes and there might then be periods

33:07

of peace and negotiation

33:09

and trade, but quickly

33:11

violence re-erups and it's

33:14

usually English aggression, sometimes

33:16

making incursions too far into

33:19

Indigenous lands for no good

33:21

reason, attacking Indigenous people, killing

33:24

them. And I think

33:26

even when the Jamestown colonists return in

33:28

1607, so this is 30 years later,

33:31

you know, the

33:33

local people haven't forgotten who the English

33:36

are. You know, there are lasting memories

33:38

and impacts of this earlier

33:40

period of violence and

33:42

how that would have played out in,

33:46

you know, the kind of mystery of the

33:48

lost colony. You can imagine that there would

33:50

have been lots of local groups who would

33:52

have been very unwilling to give shelter to

33:54

these colonists, even if they were by that

33:56

point, you know, mostly women and children. They

33:58

would remember the earlier violence. of

34:01

lanes, settlements in 1585 and

34:04

86 when lots of indigenous

34:06

people lost their lives. So they have

34:09

little reason really to provide shelter

34:11

and protection to these English

34:13

settlers. And you mentioned violence

34:15

there, Misha, and we know that one

34:18

of the settlers was killed very

34:20

early on in the settlement by

34:22

an indigenous American. And then John

34:25

White and Mantayo are some of

34:27

the people that lead this retaliatory

34:29

raid that goes terribly

34:31

wrong because they end up killing the

34:34

wrong group of indigenous Americans.

34:36

And that then brings more violence

34:38

their way. John is sent home

34:40

to London to look for reinforcements.

34:43

He leaves in August 1587. And

34:46

this is just barely a month after they've arrived.

34:48

But he then can't get back to

34:50

the colony. So what is it that keeps him

34:52

away for so long? And why can't he get

34:55

back to them? So it's

34:57

Elizabeth's order that no ships would be

34:59

allowed to return because of the Spanish

35:01

armada. So in order to try and

35:04

get round this, what John does is

35:06

hires two smaller pinnaces to try and

35:08

make his way across, but he can't.

35:10

And then he does manage

35:13

to get there in 1590. Again,

35:15

he's had to hire

35:18

three smaller ships. And this is after

35:20

really begging Raleigh as well for Raleigh's

35:23

support for him to provide shipping. And

35:25

it's when he makes that return in 1590 that

35:27

he realises that the colony

35:29

has been abandoned and finds

35:31

this carving on the post

35:33

that might suggest what's

35:35

happened to them. And

35:56

this, of course, is where the

35:58

mystery comes in. It's

36:06

1590 now, three years after he

36:09

left to get help, and John

36:11

White has finally returned to Roanoke.

36:14

The story of his return has the

36:16

logic of a nightmare to it,

36:18

a jumble of confusing signs and

36:20

traces and ultimately a feeling

36:23

of helpless dread. On

36:25

the 15th of August 1590, White

36:28

and a small crew rode a

36:31

boat through shallow inlets towards Roanoke

36:33

Island. As night fell,

36:35

they tied the vessel up near the

36:37

shoreline and waited for the dawn before

36:39

setting foot on it. In

36:42

the dark hours, they saw smoke

36:44

rising above the treetops. The

36:47

group in the boat sang hymns

36:49

hoping to hear voices answering them

36:51

through the dark and confirmation that

36:53

the colonists were there and well.

36:56

At daybreak they went ashore and headed

36:58

for the spot where White had left

37:00

the colonists three years earlier. On

37:03

the way, they saw footprints in the

37:06

sand and a tree on top of

37:08

a sandbank with the letters C-R-O

37:13

carved into it. White

37:15

took this as a secret sign of some

37:17

kind. Finally around

37:20

a corner they saw the colony itself,

37:23

or rather the desolate remains of it.

37:26

All of the houses had been knocked down.

37:29

Detritus was strewn everywhere.

37:32

There was no sign of life. A

37:35

tall perimeter fence had been built around

37:37

the houses from giant trees. On

37:40

one of these a word had been carved. It

37:43

started with the same three letters as

37:45

they'd seen before, but this time it

37:47

went on. E-R-O-A-T-O-A-N.

37:54

Croatoan. That was it.

37:57

Nothing more than footsteps and

37:59

smoke and marks on a tree,

38:01

this was all that John White

38:03

could find so far from home

38:05

in search of a group that

38:08

included, let's not forget, his daughter

38:10

and granddaughter. What must

38:12

he have felt? What had

38:14

happened here? And where had

38:17

the Lost Colonists gone? Sorry

38:23

now, hold on, hold on, hold on. I

38:26

am no expert in

38:29

16th century settler culture

38:31

in America, but this doesn't seem

38:33

that mysterious to me at all. Your

38:35

man's gone for three years, and he

38:37

comes back, and this relatively small settlement

38:39

is no longer where he left it.

38:42

I mean, this is very early days. We're not

38:44

even into the 17th century when things start to

38:46

be maybe a little bit more formalised, so they

38:49

just got up and they left, surely. Misha, help

38:51

me. So,

38:54

I mean, there are different theories

38:56

about what might have happened. So

38:58

in the early 17th century, the

39:00

Jamestown colonists hear from Chief Powhatan,

39:02

who is a local leader and

39:04

the father of Pocahontas, that

39:07

his people had killed all

39:09

the colonists. But they also

39:12

hear reports that indigenous people

39:14

are claiming English ancestry. Later

39:17

in the 18th century, people report seeing

39:19

indigenous people who have grey eyes, and

39:21

this must mean that they also have

39:23

English ancestry, and they report having

39:26

grandparents and great-grandparents who read books

39:28

and were always waiting for rallieship

39:30

to return. I think probably what

39:32

most historians agree on now is

39:35

that possibly some of the group was

39:38

dispersed, might have been absorbed into local

39:40

indigenous communities. Most likely if

39:42

that happened, it would have included women

39:44

and children, but if there

39:47

was another outbreak of conflict, you

39:49

know, the men would likely have been killed.

39:51

But then how you square that with, I

39:53

guess, the physical evidence that, you

39:55

know, the houses were pulled down suggests that

39:58

maybe the group did choose to leave, as

40:00

you're kind of thinking and kind of move

40:02

around trying to seek shelter, but any number

40:04

of things could have then happened to them

40:07

really. Now, as a

40:09

historian of graffiti, I have

40:11

to ask about the carved

40:13

word, Croatoan. Why

40:16

do you think it is

40:18

carved? Is it carved by the colonists?

40:21

Is it carved by someone

40:23

who has wished them

40:25

harm? What can we glean from

40:27

this tiny piece of evidence? Well,

40:30

the word is both the name of

40:32

a place, but also the people that

40:34

inhabit that place. So I guess

40:36

the clue is that this is where we have

40:38

gone, where we're seeking shelter with these people. But,

40:41

you know, it could also mean, you know, we're

40:43

facing a threat from these people and

40:46

this is why we've had to leave. I think

40:48

these letters were clearly left for John

40:50

White. And it does make me think

40:52

about the fact that his son-in-law was

40:54

a stone carver. So you do wonder

40:57

whether the husband of Elinor Dare might

40:59

have actually made this carving himself. But

41:01

equally, I mean, you will know from your work that,

41:03

you know, they would have had tools at hand. Anyone

41:06

really that was survived at that point could

41:08

have made the carving into the wooden post.

41:10

It would have been a fairly, I guess,

41:12

soft material to work with as well. So

41:15

probably wouldn't have taken too much force or

41:17

skill. But yeah, I mean, I think

41:19

really the mystery or the reasons

41:22

why it has been mythologised, I

41:24

think, is because the sense in

41:26

which for a long

41:28

time and even at the time, English settlers wanted

41:30

to hold on to this idea that some of

41:33

them had made it. And that from 1587 onwards,

41:35

there has been an

41:37

English presence in North America. And this

41:39

happened earlier than Jamestown and it happened

41:41

even earlier than the pilgrims, you know,

41:44

right back into the 16th century. That

41:47

kind of wanting to stake a claim right

41:49

from the 16th century that there was this

41:51

English presence, I think is one of the

41:53

reasons that it's become such

41:55

a myth and such an origin story

41:57

for people in the US and historians

41:59

as well. still fascinated by it and what

42:01

might have happened to the people. But

42:03

today, there isn't much

42:06

that remains in terms of archaeological evidence and

42:08

actually archaeologists have really struggled to find where

42:10

this site might have been, which obviously could provide

42:12

lots of clues about what might have happened to the

42:14

settlers. That's fascinating and I

42:17

really like that insight of it

42:20

benefits the colonial

42:22

narrative for this to be

42:24

more of a myth than potentially it might

42:26

have been. Part of that myth making is

42:29

Virginia Dare, this very dramatic name. Can you

42:31

tell us a little bit of what we

42:33

know about her, but then the myth that's

42:35

grown up around her too? Yeah,

42:37

I mean, so you've already said obviously

42:39

she's named after the region. She's the

42:41

first English child to be born in

42:43

North America, but we don't know

42:46

what happened to her, whether or

42:48

not she survived, but she looms

42:50

really large in American culture,

42:52

particularly in the 19th century and

42:54

into the early 20th century. She

42:56

appears in lots of works of

42:58

fiction in 1937 when there is

43:01

the 350th

43:04

anniversary of the settlement and

43:06

all the commemorative coins which

43:08

are minted and stamps. Eleanor

43:10

and Virginia, that image, well,

43:12

an imagined image of them

43:14

features quite prominently on

43:17

these creations. So they become

43:19

very much a part of

43:21

the visual culture associated with

43:23

early English colonisation in

43:25

a way that is particularly unique. So

43:27

I guess the only other figure that

43:30

has become so mythologised and whose image

43:32

has been reproduced to the same extent

43:34

is Pocahontas. And I think it's for

43:36

similar reasons. It's about this sense of

43:39

establishing an English identity in North America,

43:41

one which is feminine and

43:44

pure and Christianised as well,

43:46

importantly. And I guess the birth

43:48

of Virginia, what it symbolises is

43:50

the birth of a new English

43:52

America, but one which is explicitly

43:54

white as well. And I think

43:56

that's important, you know, this desire

43:58

to ever change. established

44:00

this white Sutter community right

44:02

back in the 16th century

44:04

that continues obviously until today.

44:07

Yeah, it's interesting, isn't it, that even

44:09

today she, the idea of her

44:11

is kind of perpetuated by white

44:13

supremacists really, and she's become this

44:15

kind of anti-immigration symbol, which of

44:17

course is incredibly ironic. Her family

44:19

were immigrants to that country, and

44:21

yes, she is the first English-born

44:24

person potentially in the American

44:27

continent. But, you know,

44:29

we talk a lot on After Dark about how stories

44:31

from the past are kind of emptied of

44:33

their original context and used in

44:35

new ways, and I think we absolutely see

44:38

that. It's so interesting to me that

44:40

you kind of make the comparison now

44:42

or the connection with Pocahontas, and you

44:44

mentioned earlier that Pocahontas' father is involved

44:47

in this story, and he really is

44:49

in that history, whether they have been

44:51

a similar age, Virginia Dare and Pocahontas,

44:53

and has anyone written a

44:55

book that puts the two of them together

44:57

because I need that book? Well,

45:00

there are certainly fictionalised accounts that when I

45:02

was doing some of the research for coming

45:05

on this podcast, learned that Virginia

45:07

Dare has features in these kind of

45:09

romance novels where John White

45:11

can't choose between her and Pocahontas,

45:13

so it is interesting the ways

45:15

in which these women have been

45:17

cast together because of their connections

45:19

in this earlier continent. They are

45:21

incredibly symbolic for how English

45:24

people at the time imagine this colonial project.

45:26

So, Pocahontas, it's about, you know, we are

45:28

going to, you know, convert the

45:30

Indigenous people, we are going to, you know,

45:32

quote, civilise them, and that's what she represents

45:34

for them. And I guess, Eleanor and Virginia,

45:36

on the other hand, is, you know, this

45:38

is the work that our English women are

45:40

going to do, they're going to go, they're

45:42

going to give birth to the next generation,

45:45

they're going to spread our language, our customs,

45:47

our religion. So women's images,

45:49

women's bodies are

45:51

doing all kinds of work for

45:53

the colonial project, and that is

45:55

both Indigenous women, but also white

45:57

European women. I think it's so

45:59

fascinating you thinking about... the reality of maybe

46:01

what happened to particularly the women like

46:03

Eleanor and Virginia. And I suppose

46:06

the reality is that they maybe died

46:08

of starvation, that they were killed,

46:10

or that they were consentingly assimilated

46:12

into local communities, indigenous communities. And

46:14

it's so fascinating to me that

46:16

if that was the case and

46:18

they were absorbed in that way

46:21

into a different culture, that

46:24

what they represent today is so at

46:26

odds with that. And it's such a

46:28

fascinating tension, and that gap between the

46:30

reality of this history and

46:33

the storytelling around it, that gray area

46:35

that's so hard to access and it's so hard

46:37

to filter truth and

46:39

storytelling. That's so tantalising.

46:42

Do you think that's the reason why

46:45

we return to the story again and again, that

46:47

these lost settlers, the reality of what happened to

46:49

them, the stories that we tell about them, it's

46:51

so compelling. Is that it? Is that what draws

46:53

us in? I think one

46:55

of the reasons that this story continues

46:57

to fascinate people is because it does

47:00

open a window into all different kinds

47:02

of hopes and anxieties that both the

47:04

settlers had at the time, but also

47:07

ones which continue to fascinate,

47:10

but also concern Americans over

47:12

several centuries, and particularly around

47:14

relations between white European settlers

47:17

and Native Americans as well. And

47:19

I think that is very much at the heart

47:21

of this story, whether or not

47:23

the colonists might have integrated and whether integration

47:25

was possible at the time, as well, is

47:27

obviously a key concern. I think one of

47:30

the reasons that people are so interested in

47:33

this story. And as Maddie was

47:35

saying, there's this tension between the fiction and the

47:37

fact, or the few facts that we do know,

47:39

I suppose. Can you tell us

47:41

a little bit about the dare stone, apparently

47:44

a message that was left by

47:46

Virginia, which is dubious in its

47:48

origins, I believe? Yeah,

47:50

and actually, and it's interesting that

47:52

these stones first appeared in 1937,

47:56

so the same year that these coins are

47:58

being minted, these stamps are being created,

48:00

you know, the play The Lost Colony

48:02

is staged for the first time down

48:05

at the site so there's a real

48:07

kind of cultural fascination at this time.

48:10

Several local so-called, well some of them

48:12

are real historians, some of them are

48:14

kind of pretenders essentially, kind of keep

48:16

discovering these these stones that tell this

48:18

very elaborate story of what happened to

48:20

the colonists. Much of

48:22

them are revealed shortly after as

48:25

Bean hoaxes and fakes, it's about

48:27

48 of them in total, but

48:30

there is still a huge question mark over

48:32

the first stone whether or not it could

48:34

be genuine. Some people have inspected the language

48:36

and the handwriting and say, you know, it

48:38

seems very much of the time, it seems

48:40

to be genuine Elizabethan English, but I do

48:42

unto myself, you know, how difficult

48:45

it would have been to forge

48:47

something like that, you know, if you

48:49

have some grasp on Shakespearean English and

48:51

a little bit of imagination, it's really

48:53

hard to say and I think historians

48:55

understandably are not keen to kind of

48:57

stake their reputations on really trying to

48:59

get to the truth of this because

49:01

I think it is problematic and away

49:03

it goes back to this issue of,

49:05

you know, why are we so fascinated

49:08

with wanting to sort of establish that,

49:10

you know, these people survived and there

49:12

have been white Americans in America since

49:14

the 16th century, so I think it's

49:16

just become so complex, so complicated and

49:18

so embroiled in white

49:20

supremacy and anti-immigration

49:23

rhetoric and anti-native feeling

49:25

and sentiment as well,

49:27

particularly in the 19th century

49:29

that I think, yeah, it's troubling really to

49:31

think about the ways in which the kind

49:33

of myths have continued to expand and change,

49:36

but I think some of that fascination nowadays

49:38

is more to do with, I guess, trying

49:40

to understand, you know, the history of colonization

49:42

itself, you know, the archaeology of the site

49:45

and what society would have been like and

49:47

the lessons that, you know, that might have

49:49

for the wider understandings of colonization in

49:51

the 16th and 17th centuries. Misha,

49:54

thank you so much for taking

49:57

us back to the Lost Colony

49:59

and really digging

50:01

down into those

50:03

myths, the history and those gaps in

50:05

between that are so fascinating and that

50:08

keep us coming back and returning again

50:10

and again. Thank you also, listener, for

50:12

spending time with us today on After

50:14

Dark. You can access our entire back

50:16

catalogue wherever you get your podcasts and

50:18

don't forget to leave us a five

50:20

star review. It helps other people discover

50:23

the podcast and helps us grow, which

50:25

is no bad thing. See you next

50:27

time. Acast

50:38

powers the world's best podcasts.

50:41

Here's a show that we recommend. Food

50:46

Network Obsessed is your podcast for all

50:49

things Food Network. I'm

50:51

Jamie Sire and I talk with

50:53

your favorite chefs, food influencers, and

50:55

Food Network personalities. They tell

50:57

me all about how they started their careers,

50:59

who and what they've been influenced by, and

51:01

what it's like to cook in a Food

51:03

Network studio. You'll hear

51:05

from stars like Alex Guarnaschelli, Guy Fieri,

51:08

and Bobby Flay. Listen

51:10

to Food Network Obsessed wherever you get your

51:12

podcasts. Acast

51:17

helps creators launch, grow, and

51:19

monetize their podcasts everywhere.

51:22

acast.com. acast.com.

51:26

Hey, Prime members. You can listen

51:28

to this show ad-free on Amazon

51:30

Music. Download the Amazon Music app

51:32

today.

Unlock more with Podchaser Pro

  • Audience Insights
  • Contact Information
  • Demographics
  • Charts
  • Sponsor History
  • and More!
Pro Features